Hi all , another newb here
I wonder if anyone might be able to help identify this dining table & chairs set. It's advertised as Hans olsen it is very similar in style to the set by Hans Olsen for Frem Røjle but the chair & table legs are a bit straighter and the chair backs different.
Thoughts & comments very welcome on whether this is genuine style variance or just a design copy.
Thanks
The closer photo has the impression that all of the wood and upholstery is fairly new. Combined with detail differences, my guess would be that it is fairly recent production (probably unlicensed). If you could get photos of the undersides of the table and chairs, that would help make it more definitive.
I don’t know how long Frem produced this series but it was often the case that makers slightly changed designs during the seventies. Frem was active until around 1981. I wouldn’t exclude the possibility that this is a seventies production.
"People buy a chair, and they don't really care who designed it." (Arne Jacobsen)
@kyle-barrett The roundette was one the few pieces that really struck me when I saw it for the first time. I wouldn’t want it in my home I think, but it is such a clever design. Hans Olsen was underrated as a designer and inventor.
"People buy a chair, and they don't really care who designed it." (Arne Jacobsen)
My opinion on it is less favourable! Haha.
- Having sat on one of the three-legged versions (though, of course there is a four-legged version, which I will come back to) it does not feel particularly comfortable or stable, I would not enjoy dining in it for a longer period.
- On it's own merit the chair is quite ugly with just vertical lines and on it's own merit the table is ugly with the inconsistent apron. Neither designs look particularly nice unless they are together and nicely packed away.
- The packed away aspect itself, feels like gimmick rather than function, most chairs tuck sufficiently into a table to look neat and prevent obstruction. The design skates by on this gimmick alone, which was not new in the period of it's conception.
- Finally coming back to the earlier point of the four-legged version. As if I didn't already lack trust in the design itself on the above levels, when you see the rectangular table variation and the four-legged version it feels like there wasn't really any aesthetic requisite that was being followed. Those deviant variations existing makes the design feel even less deliberate and thoughtful.
But, that is rather scathing and they do look nice when they're all packed away as a set! Well the round one does anway.
With warmest criticisms to the respectable Mr Olsen, 😆
Kyle
@kyle-barrett Touché! 🙂 I can follow your arguments. This is probably why I said, I wouldn't want it in my home. I just like how it looks as a set and I still find it clever and pleasing on an aesthetic level. Especially nice for small rooms. But I can't tell whether the chairs are comfortable. I haven't sat on them.
"People buy a chair, and they don't really care who designed it." (Arne Jacobsen)
If you need any help, please contact us at – info@designaddict.com