Second thoughts,
I previously stated on this post that i thought this desk looked a little dated and generic looking.I have had chance since then to sober up (a little) and now im of the opinion that its just horrible and the wood has a look of cheapo stain.Yes, i am an alcoholic and will remain so as long as i can afford to be thanks.
Thanks
Thanks Marvin, I have and MA in fine arts. The desk and most of Jason Lees designs are very derivative of the pre WWll modernist aesthetic as espoused by designers like Gilbret Rohde and Russell Wright. Rohde did exactly these legs (but not in zebrawood) and several of Lees pieces are clearly immitating Rohdes designs for Herman Miller in the 30's. Look at the dresser on Lees home page:
http://www.jasonleesdesign.com/
and look at this dresser in the Brooklyn Museum:
http://www.brooklynmuseum.org/research/luce/object.php?id=112099
Thanks
Thanks Marvin, I have and MA in fine arts. The desk and most of Jason Lees designs are very derivative of the pre WWll modernist aesthetic as espoused by designers like Gilbret Rohde and Russell Wright. Rohde did exactly these legs (but not in zebrawood) and several of Lees pieces are clearly immitating Rohdes designs for Herman Miller in the 30's. Look at the dresser on Lees home page:
and look at this dresser in the Brooklyn Museum:
and your point is?
Why does inspiration render a design derivative? I'm not a design student or nuthin', so maybe my opinion is not of interest to you folks with masters degrees, but all I see is some good looking furntiture with a nod to the past. Have you actually ever seen Ikea? Cause this ain't that.
perspectives
I am in agreement with those who point out that it does not take an advanced design or art degree to have a conversation about a piece of furtniture. And while we all have our aesthetic likes and dislikes, it's exclusive terminology like "derivative" that has the potential to limit the dialogue to those who have the historical background to understand it's meaning in the context used here--
That said, thank you JC for unpacking what you meant by derivative-- and for giving visuals for our reference. I know I appreciate a variety of perspectives in forums such as this one, however am wondering if others feel the same way--
The horse ain't quite dead yet
This is the style I was thinking of when I said the desk was Ikea like. I should have said Danish. Mr. Lees clearly has skill and good taste. I wish he would partner his skill with someone who has new ideas about furniture but lacks the skill with wood. The right partnership could revitalize the use of wood to make good, modern furniture.
Think of what Norm Abrams (this old house) and a good designer could create instead of Norms lovely but eclectic (in a bad way) copies of 19th c and earlier antiques.
My apologies to Mr. Lees, it's just that the potential ... Ah well, the horse is now officially deceased.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ih=006&sspagename=STRK%3AM...
If you need any help, please contact us at – info@designaddict.com