Neither.
I really like the felt seatpads and backpads made by Parkhaus in Germany.
For the Bertoia side chair, they make a two-piece set that attractively exposes some of the wire on the seatback.
Catalog linked below:
http://www.parkhausberlin.de/collection/suit/PARKHAUS_Suit.pdf
Gustaf
I have a pair of side chairs in yellow and the Knoll yellow vinyl seat cushions make a world of difference in terms of comfort. They are perfectly appropriate and swell; you don't need leather...the vinyl seat cushions look high-end. (Make sure you get real Knoll cushions; the cheap copies look and feel cheap!)
If you need any help, please contact us at – info@designaddict.com